Follow Your Heart Logo
  • Products
    • VIEW ALL
    • VEGENAISE
    • DAIRY-FREE CHEESE
    • SUPERMAC
    • SALAD DRESSINGS
    • BREAKFAST
    • DIPS & SPREADS
  • Recipes
    • FEATURED
    • BREAKFAST
    • MAIN DISHES
    • APPETIZERS
    • DESSERTS
    • SAUCES
  • About
    • ABOUT US
    • SUSTAINABILITY
    • FAQs
    • NEWS
    • CONTACT US
    • FOOD SERVICE
  • Store Locator
  • Market & Café
Menu
  • Products
    • VIEW ALL
    • VEGENAISE
    • DAIRY-FREE CHEESE
    • SUPERMAC
    • SALAD DRESSINGS
    • BREAKFAST
    • DIPS & SPREADS
  • Recipes
    • FEATURED
    • BREAKFAST
    • MAIN DISHES
    • APPETIZERS
    • DESSERTS
    • SAUCES
  • About
    • ABOUT US
    • SUSTAINABILITY
    • FAQs
    • NEWS
    • CONTACT US
    • FOOD SERVICE
  • Store Locator
  • Market & Café

Is Carrageenan Safe?

As a leader in innovative plant-based foods, ­Follow Your Heart is committed to the quality and safety of our ingredients. One ingredient that is particularly in the spotlight is carrageenan. Some Follow Your Heart products contain carrageenan and we would like to provide you with information about why we choose to use it and why we are confident the carrageenan that we use is a safe food ingredient in our products.

 

Is Carrageenan safe?

Yes, our extensive research has led us to conclude that food-grade carrageenan is safe to eat.

 

What is Carrageenan?

Red SeaweedCarrageenan is an ingredient derived from red seaweed that works as a thickener in foods. The name Carrageenan is derived from “[a] species of seaweed known as Carrageen Moss or Irish Moss in England, and Carraigin in Ireland. Carraigin has been used in Ireland since 400 AD as a gelatin and as a home remedy to cure coughs and colds (1).”

 

 

Why is there concern about Carrageenan?

There are two forms of carrageenan: food-grade and degraded. Food grade carrageenan has been used for hundreds of years and has been extensively reviewed and approved for use in foods. Degraded carrageenan was found to be harmful, but is not used in foods, as it does not provide any thickening properties. Even though degraded carrageenan and food-grade carrageenan are different, the harmful effects of carrageenan in its degraded form have been mistakenly associated with food-grade carrageenan.

 

How do we know that Carrageenan is a safe food additive?

Food-grade carrageenan has been independently evaluated by the Joint FAO*/WHO** Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA), an international panel of expert toxicologists who review data and develop recommendations about food ingredients. JECFA determined that food-grade carrageenan was a safe food additive with no limits on its use in food.

 

Carrageenan-process

 

 

Conclusion

Follow Your Heart is committed to the quality and safety of our ingredients. We know that our customers expect us to use only the highest quality and healthiest ingredients available, and we do everything we can to satisfy those expectations. We feel confident in our choice to use food-grade carrageenan and its alignment with our mission to make wholesome, healthy plant-based foods. You can read more about the research we conducted to make our decision below. If you have any other questions, please email us at info@followyourheart.com.

 

 


 

Here’s the summary of our research:

 

What is Carrageenan?

Carrageenan, an ingredient derived from various species of red seaweed, has been used for hundreds of years as a thickener in foods (2) and was first made commercially in 1940 for chocolate milk and junket (3), a milk dessert similar to pudding. In the mid 1960’s, it was common for doctors to recommend carrageenan to reduce pain associated with peptic ulcers. The concentration needed to provide ulcer relief created a gel that was extremely viscous and unpleasant to consume. Subsequently, degraded carrageenan, also known as poligeenan, was created. Degraded carrageenan is produced by hydrolyzing native (food grade) carrageenan which cuts bonds and makes the molecules smaller thus removing their thickening properties. Soon, degraded carrageenan was found to be harmful and its use for ulcer treatment was discontinued. Since the function of carrageenan used in foods is to thicken, degraded carrageenan, having little or no thickening properties, never had a use in foods. Even though degraded carrageenan and food-grade carrageenan are different, the harmful effects of carrageenan in its degraded form have been mistakenly associated with food-grade carrageenan.

 

Why is there concern about Carrageenan?

Red SeaweedThe driving force behind concerns regarding carrageenan’s safety is attributed to an article written by Dr. Joanne Tobacman (4). Most of the studies cited in her article report on degraded carrageenan (poligeenan). She argues that even food-grade carrageenan is not safe from having significant levels of degraded carrageenan because the acids in our stomach as well as certain bacteria might break it down into degraded carrageenan. This is not a claim supported by human or animal studies. Tobacman references studies that simulate gastric acid effects on carrageenan and the resulting presence of degraded carrageenan. However, a study in 1969 by Marcus and Watt explains that “poligeenan with an average molecular weight of about 20,000 daltons has none of the food functions of carrageenan whose average molecular weight is never lower than 100,000 daltons and is usually much higher.” Therefore, comparing “digested” carrageenan to poligeenan is a false equivalency.

More recently, “scientific assessments of carrageenan have included short term and long term generational studies involving different dosages of degraded and non-degraded forms and various animal studies … all of the studies supported the safety of [food grade] carrageenan for use in foods. Regulatory authorities saw no reason to question the safety of [food grade] carrageenan as long as the average molecular weight was 100,000 daltons or higher.” The regulations of carrageenan molecular sizes were modified to insure that the food-grade carrageenan in foods was never lower than that limit, and testing methods were introduced to enforce these limits (5).

Tobacman also references studies that show that native carrageenan can promote colonic tumors in rats; however, the carrageenan in these studies made up anywhere between 2.5% and 15% of the rats’ total diets. In contrast, foods that contain carrageenan have the ingredient at tenths (.1%) or hundredths (.01%) of a percent within the food and these foods make up only a small fraction of our overall diet.

 

How do we know that carrageenan is a safe food additive?

Dr. Tobacman’s research was reviewed by the Joint FAO*/WHO** Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA), an independent international panel of expert toxicologists who review data and develop recommendations pertaining to food ingredients. Their review of the study, and of carrageenan, included an evaluation of degradation of carrageenan and “public speculation of the harmful gastrointestinal effects” of carrageenan. As a result of the evaluation, the JECFA committee determined that the studies of carrageenan on laboratory animals were conducted with high levels of degraded carrageenan (poligeenan) and that food-grade carrageenan was a safe food additive with no limits on its use in food. Those studies used a different form of carrageenan and were tested only at high use levels. The JECFA determined that carrageenan was a safe food additive with no limits on its use in food (6) and “assigned it an acceptable daily intake (ADI) of “not specified” the most favorable category. An ADI of 0-75mg/kg body weight is established in the EU” and is allowed to be used as needed (7).

 

Other studies and our take on the research

Since Tobacman’s aforementioned article, she also wrote a paper noting that bench-top invitro experiments showed interactions between carrageenan and various organ cells (8). These experiments are considered invalid because ingested carrageenan does not pass the blood-gut barrier to interact with organ cells (6). She also wrote a paper noting the “time-trend” that carrageenan consumption and the incidence of breast cancer both increased in the 20th century (9). The European Commission Scientific Committee for Food stated that such correlations might be found for any food or chemical which has increased in prevalence during the 20th century (10). We think that saying carrageenan must induce breast cancer because breast cancer incidence and carrageenan consumption both increase during the 20th century is like saying that listening to Jimi Hendrix and the prevalence of rock n roll music must also induce breast cancer.

We feel that she is doing her best to defend her case against food-grade carrageenan regardless of the science behind the arguments and is not recognizing the true difference between degraded carrageenan and food-grade carrageenan. The scientific literature we’ve read supports the safety of carrageenan and even shows carrageenan to inhibit cancer cell growth due to its enhancement of the immune system (11).

 

Conclusion

We also invite you to not just take our word for it, and welcome you to read some of the research on your own. Two good places to start are “Public Health and Carrageenan Regulation” and “Carrageenan: a review”. If you have any other questions, please email us at info@followyourheart.com.

 

*FAO = Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations

**WHO = World Health Organization

 

Sources:

1 Carrageenan: a review from Veterinarni Medicina, 58, 2013 (4): 187–205 http://vri.cz/docs/vetmed/58-4-187.pdf

2 Stanley N (1987) Production, properties and uses of carrageenan. In:McHugh DF (ed.) Production and utilization of products from commercial seaweeds, vol 288. FAO, Rome

3 Champman VJ (1950) Seaweeds and their uses. 1st ed. Camelot Press, London

4 Tobacman JK (2001) Review of harmful gastrointestinaleffects of carrageenan in animal experiments. Environ Health Perspect 109:983-994.

5 Marcus AJ, Watt J (1969) Ulcerative colitis guinea-pig caused by seaweed extract. J Pharmceut Pharmacol 21:187.

6 Watson DB (2008) Public health and carrageenan regulation: a review and analysis. J Appl Phycol 20:505-513.

7 Weiner ML, Nuber D, Blakemore WR, Harriman JF, Cohen SM (2007) A 90-day dietary study on kappa carrageenan with emphasis on the gastroinstestinal tract. Food Chem Toxicol 45:98-106.

8 Borthakur A, Bhattacharyya S, Dudeja PK, Tobacman JK (2007) Carrageenan induces interleukin-8 production through distinct Bc110 pathway in normal human colonic epithelial cells. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol 292:G829-G838.

9 Tobacman JK, Wallace RB, Zimmerman MB (2001) Consumption of carrageenan and other water-soluble polymers used as food additives and incidence of mammary carcinoma. Med Hypotheses 56:589-598.

10 Scientific Committee on Food (2003) Opinion of the Scientific Committee on Food on carrageenan. Brussels: European Commission; 5 March. (SCF/CS/ADD/EMU/199 Final)

11 Yuan H, Song J, Li X, Li N, Dai J (2006) Immunomodulation and antitumor activity of [kappa]-carrageenan oligosaccharides. Cancer Lett 243:228-234.

*Photos courtesy of the wonderful people over at Seaweed Consulting.

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL

followyourheart

View

Jun 21

Open
☀️ Happy First Day of Summer! ☀️ To celebrate the season and the return of food-filled community block parties, we're giving 10 lucky winners each $1,000 + FYH branded cooler + FYH products to throw an epic party of their own! We believe everyone should be able to join in the plant-based fun and enjoy some tasty, good times!⁠
⁠
To enter, tell us (via email: FollowYourHeartBlockParty@icfnext.com) why we should help sponsor your community’s block party. The sweepstakes runs through July 4, 2022. Click the link in our bio for full set of sweepstakes rules.⁠
⁠
Giveaway only open to US residents aged 18+. This giveaway is not affiliated or endorsed by Instagram in any way. No purchase necessary. Good luck and have fun!

followyourheart

View

Jun 17

Open
Not to sound corny, but this Elote Flatbread 🌽 from @theyummyvegan is absolutely a-MAIZE-ing. It's the perfect fusion of elote, aka Mexican Street Corn, and flatbread pizza. The best part? #Vegan Cotija cheese made with our Dairy-Free Feta Crumbles and Grated Parmesan 🧀. Don't forget a generous drizzle of tangy crema made with our creamy Original #Vegenaise. Find the recipe at the link in our bio!

followyourheart

View

Jun 15

Open
🎉 Vegenaise is turning 45 🎉! That's 45 years of the original #eggfree, #dairyfree, #plantbased spread that's #BetterThanMayo 🥪! To celebrate, we're giving away a YEAR'S supply of FYH - that's 12 free FYH product vouchers!

To enter simply comment below with your favorite way to use Vegenaise. We'll pick 1 lucky winner at random on Friday, 6/17. Giveaway only open to US residents aged 18+. This giveaway is not affiliated or endorsed by Instagram in any way. Good luck!

followyourheart

View

Jun 13

Open
Hello garlicky goodness 🧄! @trinhsvegankitchen makes eating veggies fun with these Air Fried Brussel Sprouts topped with crispy shallots and a #Vegan Lemon Garlic Aoli featuring our creamy Original #Vegenaise for next level drool-worthyness. Visit our Store locator to find a jar of Original Vegenaise near you via the link in our bio.

followyourheart

View

Jun 10

Open
Slide into the weekend with these spud-tastic Sweet Potato Falafel Sliders 🍔 from @sporkfoods. They're slathered in a Creamy Herb Sauce made with our Original #Vegenaise for a sweet and savory dish you won't want to miss. Tap the link in our bio for the recipe!

followyourheart

View

Jun 9

Open
Crumbles for the win! Sprinkle some joy with our #DairyFree Bleu Cheese and Feta Crumbles. Leave a 💙 in the comments if you're team Bleu and a 🤍 if you're team Feta. Either way, you can't lose!

followyourheart

View

Jun 7

Open
Mornings are always better when Cheesy Breakfast Potatoes 🥔 are involved. Our #DairyFree Finely Shredded Mozzarella 🧀 melts to perfection to create the cheesiest side dish you'll be craving day after day. Grab this delicious recipe from @sporkfoods at the link in our bio.

followyourheart

View

Jun 6

Open
That's a wrap! @joesveganfoodgram is dazzling our tastebuds with this flavor packed #Vegan Ultimate Chick'n Caesar Wrap 🌯. It's made with our #DairyFree Shredded Parmesan and creamy Caesar Dressing to create a majestic meal that's sure become a weeknight favorite!

followyourheart

View

Jun 1

Open
Let the gouda times roll with this #vegan BLTA from @cafe.rozay featuring our delicious and #DairyFree Smoked Gouda 🧀 Slices. Find some near you by visiting our Store Locator via the link in our bio.

followyourheart

View

May 31

Open
When life gives you lemons, make 🍋 Lemon Dill Potato Salad 🥔. This easy, creamy dish from @sporkfoods is made with our Original #Vegenaise and topped with our #DairyFree Feta Crumbles for a tangy bang. Tap the link in our bio for the recipe.

followyourheart

View

May 27

Open
☀️ ULTIMATE SUMMER BBQ GIVEAWAY! ☀️ We've partnered with our friend @plantbasedonabudget to set you up with some amazing plant-based goodies for some super tasty summer barbeques that will be sure to impress your friends! One lucky winner will receive:⁠
⁠
🧀 @followyourheart product package AND one year's supply of Vegenaise!! (12 free product coupons)⁠
📖 @plantbasedonabudget cookbook, Plant-Based on a Budget⁠
🧰 Cuisinart 20-piece BBQ tool set⁠
⁠
Head over to @plantbasedonabudget for details on how to enter!

followyourheart

View

May 25

Open
Let's get ready to crumble! @plvntfood's recipe for Brown Butter Bleu Cheese Mashed Potatoes with Port Wine Gravy is a creamy, dreamy side dish you'll want to serve with just about any dinner meal. Made with our #DairyFree Cream Cheese and Bleu Cheese Crumbles 🧀 for ultimate cheesiness, we won't blame you for forgetting the main dish! Recipe link in bio.

followyourheart

View

May 23

Open
Get your week off to a delicious start with these #Vegan Spinach Quinoa Fried Egg Rolls from @healthyish.autumn. It's paired with a homemade Sriracha Ginger Mayo dipping sauce made with our creamy Original #Vegenaise. Find a jar of Original Vegenaise near you by visiting our Store Locator via the link in bio.

followyourheart

View

May 17

Open
What's for dinner? How about these heavenly Bleu Cheese Compound Butter Portobello Mushrooms 🍄 and Baked Potatoes 🥔 from @theyummyvegan. This bleu-tiful dish is made with our #DairyFree Bleu Cheese Crumbles and will surely become a weeknight favorite! Tap the link in our bio to get the full recipe.

followyourheart

View

May 13

Open
Hummus where the heart is ❤️. Grab some veggies and dig into this Serrano Feta Hummus if you're looking for a simple snack that's equal parts spicy, savory, and superb. Don't forget the star of this dish: our #DairyFree Feta Crumbles. Recipe ➡️ link in bio.

followyourheart

View

May 12

Open
This Greek Pasta Salad recipe from @sporkfoods should be on your to-do list this week. It's loaded with fresh veggies, #vegan beef strips, and our tangy (and a little bit addicting) #DairyFree Feta Crumbles - how could you go wrong? Recipe link in bio.

followyourheart

View

May 9

Open
Get bready for sandwich perfection with this Ultimate Veggie Crunch Sandwich 🥪 from @thefirstmess. It's loaded with fresh veggies and slathered with a delicious thousand island spread made with our creamy Original #Vegenaise. Find our Original Vegenaise near you via our Store Locator, link in bio.

followyourheart

View

May 6

Open
Eating your veggies is always easy when @sporkfoods' Parmesan Crusted Cauliflower is involved. This tasty dish is tender on the inside and crispy on the outside, thanks to our #DairyFree Shredded Parmesan 🧀. Head over to the link in our bio to make this recipe yourself!

followyourheart

View

May 5

Open
In queso you're looking for some Cinco de Mayo recipe inspo, we have you covered with these #Vegan Meaty Cheezy Quesadillas from @eat_figs_not_pigs. It's made with shredded oyster mushrooms and our ooey gooey #DairyFree Finely Shredded Mozzarella and Cheddar Cheeses 🧀. Recipe link in bio.

followyourheart

View

May 4

Open
"Judge me by my flavor do you?"⁠
- Original Vegenaise, 𝘌𝘱𝘪𝘴𝘰𝘥𝘦 𝘐𝘝: 𝘉𝘦𝘵𝘵𝘦𝘳 𝘛𝘩𝘢𝘯 𝘔𝘢𝘺𝘰®⁠
⁠
Which side will you choose?

@FOLLOWYOURHEART

  • Home
  • Products
  • Recipes
  • About Us
  • Store Locator
  • Market & Café
  • Contact
  • FAQ
certified plant based

Follow Your Heart believes that a better world begins with better food choices. We make Vegenaise, the best vegan cheeses, and other delicious and innovative plant-based alternatives. Follow Your Heart® Earth Island® Vegenaise® Vegan Gourmet® Rocket Cakes® VeganEgg® Better Than Mayo® Live Healthy® are registered trademarks of Follow Your Heart®/Earth Island®

©2022 Follow Your Heart All Rights Reserved

Please share your location to continue